Basement Remodeling Meta Ads in New Jersey: $853 Spend, 4 Booked Estimates
Niche: high-ticket residential basement remodeling
Market: New Jersey, homeowners in the top 5-10% ZIP codes
Channel: Meta Ads (Facebook + Instagram), lead form
Scope: one ad account, a 14-day paid validation, January 8-21, 2026
Ad spend: $853
Leads: 141 clicks and 9 inbound leads
Booked estimates: 4 of 9 leads - about $213 per booked in-home estimate
Best week: $55 cost per lead at a 1.64% CTR
My role: I and my team ran this as a paid-channel validation - offer and audience research, campaign and audience structure, creative concepts and ad copy, the lead form, daily budget and performance management, and the lead-by-lead follow-up tracking that turned form fills into booked appointments.
Average cost per lead: $94.80 across the test - $55 in the best week.
Revenue and ROAS: not tracked in this report, so this case does not claim them.
Market: New Jersey, homeowners in the top 5-10% ZIP codes
Channel: Meta Ads (Facebook + Instagram), lead form
Scope: one ad account, a 14-day paid validation, January 8-21, 2026
Ad spend: $853
Leads: 141 clicks and 9 inbound leads
Booked estimates: 4 of 9 leads - about $213 per booked in-home estimate
Best week: $55 cost per lead at a 1.64% CTR
My role: I and my team ran this as a paid-channel validation - offer and audience research, campaign and audience structure, creative concepts and ad copy, the lead form, daily budget and performance management, and the lead-by-lead follow-up tracking that turned form fills into booked appointments.
Average cost per lead: $94.80 across the test - $55 in the best week.
Revenue and ROAS: not tracked in this report, so this case does not claim them.
Where Things Stood at the Start
A New Jersey remodeling contractor that designs and builds fully finished basements - framing to final details, typically in about 45 days, with a five-year workmanship warranty and 15+ years behind the crew. The work and the crews were not the problem. Predictable demand was - which is why the owner came to me and my team to find out whether a paid channel could fill the schedule.
A six-figure product, no paid channel
A finished basement is a large, considered purchase. The company had never proven that paid social could reach the right homeowner at a price that made sense - and nobody wants to learn that by burning a five-figure budget.
Interest, not intent
Nobody searches for a basement remodel the way they search for an emergency plumber. The demand has to be created: the homeowner has to be shown that the largest unused room in the house is worth something.
The wrong homeowner is expensive
A lead from the wrong ZIP code costs exactly as much as a lead from a $3M property and is worth a fraction of it. Targeting had to buy the right address, not the cheapest click.
Form fills are not appointments
In this niche the number that matters is the booked in-home estimate. Without disciplined day-by-day follow-up logging, a lead is just a row in a spreadsheet.
What We Did
One ad account, one offer, one state - a deliberately small, deliberately fast validation.
Here is what actually moved the numbers.
Here is what actually moved the numbers.
Analyzed the business, the offer and the buying process, and built the campaign around the strongest commercial hook - a free design and estimate with a 45-day build
Targeted homeowners in the top 5-10% New Jersey ZIP codes rather than a broad statewide audience
Built the lead form around qualifying questions - approximate basement size and preferred estimate date - so the sales team could triage before calling
Tested two creative formats against the same audience: a single-image "your basement is wasted space" ad and a carousel
Managed budget daily and re-weighted spend toward the format and messaging that produced qualified conversations
Tracked every lead through a logged Day 1-Day 5 call and SMS follow-up sequence, so the reporting measured booked estimates, not form fills
The Results
Fourteen days of delivery, January 8-21, 2026. Spend, impressions, clicks, CTR, CPC and leads come straight from the campaign report. Booked estimates come from the lead-by-lead follow-up log kept with the client. Revenue and ROAS were not tracked in this report, so they are not claimed here.
- Total ad spend: $853 across 14 days of delivery
- 14,358 impressions and 141 clicks at a 0.98% CTR - $6.05 average cost per click
- 9 inbound leads at a $94.80 average cost per lead
- Best week (Jan 8-11): $166 spend, 3 leads, $55 cost per lead at a 1.64% CTR
- 4 of 9 leads (44%) became booked appointments and received estimates - about $213 per booked estimate
- Client-reported: one project closed on an approximately $3M property, with an estimated project value of around $200,000
The campaign report itself, Jan 8-21, 2026: $853 ad spend, 14,358 impressions, 141 clicks, 9 leads at a $95 average cost per lead. Best week (Jan 8-11): $166 spend, 3 leads at $55 CPL and a 1.64% CTR. Client name and lead details removed; the Revenue and ROAS columns were never filled.
From impression to appointment: 14,358 impressions, 141 clicks, 9 leads, 4 booked in-home estimates - about $213 per booked estimate. Eight of the nine leads came from the single-image ad. Booked estimates come from the lead-by-lead Day 1-Day 5 follow-up log kept with the client.
The Key Insight
At an $853 test budget, the interesting number is not the cost per lead. It is the cost per booked estimate - about $213 - in a category where a single signed project runs into six figures. That is the ratio that tells an owner whether the channel is worth funding, and it is the reason a test this small was still able to answer a big question.
Three things drove it.
The format did the selling, not the budget. Eight of the nine leads came from one single-image ad built on a single uncomfortable observation: the basement is the largest unused room in the house. The carousel produced one. That is a creative result, not a spend result - and it is the cheapest kind of insight to buy, because it costs a fortnight rather than a quarter.
The audience bought the address. Concentrating on the top 5-10% ZIP codes rather than the whole state is what put a $3M property into a nine-lead list. In a high-ticket trade, targeting is not an efficiency lever, it is a revenue lever: the same cost per lead against the wrong homeowner is simply a worse business.
Follow-up is where the money is. Nine leads became four booked estimates because every one of them was worked through a logged Day 1-Day 5 call and SMS sequence. The leads that went cold in the report are the ones that went unanswered twice on day one. Meta Ads bought the conversation. The follow-up is what turned it into an appointment.
And the honest limit of this test: two weeks and nine leads is a direction, not a forecast. The client reported that one project closed out of it, on an approximately $3M property with an estimated value of around $200,000 - their account, not a tracked figure, because revenue was never in the report. The next step is not a bigger budget. It is revenue tracking in a CRM, so the next $853 can be judged on closed projects instead of booked estimates.
Three things drove it.
The format did the selling, not the budget. Eight of the nine leads came from one single-image ad built on a single uncomfortable observation: the basement is the largest unused room in the house. The carousel produced one. That is a creative result, not a spend result - and it is the cheapest kind of insight to buy, because it costs a fortnight rather than a quarter.
The audience bought the address. Concentrating on the top 5-10% ZIP codes rather than the whole state is what put a $3M property into a nine-lead list. In a high-ticket trade, targeting is not an efficiency lever, it is a revenue lever: the same cost per lead against the wrong homeowner is simply a worse business.
Follow-up is where the money is. Nine leads became four booked estimates because every one of them was worked through a logged Day 1-Day 5 call and SMS sequence. The leads that went cold in the report are the ones that went unanswered twice on day one. Meta Ads bought the conversation. The follow-up is what turned it into an appointment.
And the honest limit of this test: two weeks and nine leads is a direction, not a forecast. The client reported that one project closed out of it, on an approximately $3M property with an estimated value of around $200,000 - their account, not a tracked figure, because revenue was never in the report. The next step is not a bigger budget. It is revenue tracking in a CRM, so the next $853 can be judged on closed projects instead of booked estimates.
Free Consultation Request
Watch the welcome video.
I explain the marketing problems companies run into most often, and when I can genuinely help.
I explain the marketing problems companies run into most often, and when I can genuinely help.
Watch the short welcome video before you fill out the form
Please fill out every field carefully so that I or my assistant can get in touch with you.